Legally Reviewed by:

Jonathan Rosenfeld

August 19, 2023

Over $400 Million worth of case results

Awarded The Best Lawyer in 2024 by U.S. News

Nationally Recognized in Legal Community

The term indictment often appears in legal contexts, but what does it mean, and how does it affect individuals involved in the legal process?

Understanding the concept is crucial for anyone navigating the criminal justice system, especially for those who may be victims of negligence or wrongdoing.

What Does Indictment Mean?

Definition and Importance of an Indictment

An indictment by a grand jury formally accuses a person suspected of committing a crime.

It is a critical step in criminal justice, signaling that there is enough evidence to proceed with a criminal trial.

It is a formal notice outlining the accused’s specific criminal charges.

The Role of Grand Juries in Indictments

Grand juries play a vital role in the process.

Grand jury members review the prosecutor’s evidence and decide whether there is sufficient evidence to proceed with criminal charges.

Unlike a trial jury, grand jurors do not determine an innocent or guilty verdict but assess whether there is a reasonable basis for the charges.

When Does a Prosecutor Need to Get an Indictment?

The process of obtaining an indictment varies between jurisdictions and depends on the nature of the crime.

Federal Requirements

In federal cases, a federal grand jury must issue an indictment for felony offenses.

The federal government follows specific federal laws and procedures, ensuring that the Fifth Amendment requirement of the Constitution is met.

Federal indictments are a crucial part of the legal process at the federal level.

State Laws Regarding Indictments

State law varies; not all states require an indictment for felony charges and a criminal complaint may be used in many states.

Understanding the specific requirements of state law is essential for anyone involved in a legal case at the state level.

How Does a Prosecutor Get an Indictment?

Obtaining an indictment involves a detailed legal process, often involving a grand jury.

Presenting Evidence to a Grand Jury

The prosecutor presents evidence to the grand jury, including witnesses, documents, and other materials.

The grand jurors review the evidence to determine if sufficient evidence supports the criminal charges.

The prosecutor guides the grand jury but does not participate in their deliberations.

The Voting Process within a Grand Jury

Most grand juries must agree that there is sufficient evidence for an indictment.

If the grand jury reaches this conclusion, they issue a “true bill,” leading to the formal accusation.

If not, they return a “no bill,” and the charges are dismissed.

Why Would a Prosecutor Get an Indictment?

The decision to seek an indictment involving a formal criminal complaint is complex and multifaceted.

The prosecutor must follow legal requirements, including the Fifth Amendment when seeking an indictment, as seen in the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office.

In criminal cases, the prosecutor must demonstrate probable cause that the accused has committed a crime.

This means that there must be sufficient evidence to believe that the individual has committed felony charges or other criminal charges.

The prosecutor decides whether to pursue the process based on various factors, including:

  • Evidence strength
  • Nature of the crime
  • Other strategic considerations

Political Implications and Secrecy in Proceedings

In high-profile cases, political implications may influence the decision to seek an indictment.

For example, the Manhattan grand jury investigation of former President Donald Trump drew significant public attention.

The secrecy of grand jury proceedings allows the prosecutor to investigate without public scrutiny, maintaining the integrity of the process.

The Process Following a State or Federal Indictment

After an indictment, the accused may be arrested, and the case proceeds to trial, where the defendant has the right to a defense attorney.

During this process, the accused is found guilty or innocent.

What Happens If You Are Indicted?

Being indicted is a serious legal matter, and understanding the process is crucial.

Notification, Arrest, and Prosecution

Upon indictment, the accused is notified, possibly arrested, and the criminal trial begins.

The prosecutor pursues the case, and the defendant can build a defense with defense lawyers.

If indicted, seeking legal assistance from a defense attorney is vital.

Defense lawyers can help build a strong defense, protect the accused’s rights, and navigate the complex legal process.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Our experienced attorneys at Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers, LLC have compiled a list of frequently asked questions to clarify the complex subject of indictments.

These questions and answers aim to demystify the legal process involving grand juries, federal prosecutors, and the court system.

What Does Indictment Mean?

Being indicted means a grand jury has found sufficient evidence to charge a person with a crime.

An indictment is an accusation that initiates the criminal process.

The defendant will then face criminal charges, and the case may be tried.

What’s the Difference Between Being Charged or Indicted?

Being charged is an accusation made by a prosecutor, while being indicted requires a grand jury’s decision.

The standard for an indictment is reasonable doubt, while a charge may require a lower threshold of evidence.

What Is an Example of Indicted?

An example of being indicted is when a grand jury issues a ‘true bill’ against a high-profile individual, such as the case involving potential crimes at Mar-a-Lago.

It is a formal step in the legal process, indicating enough evidence to proceed with criminal charges.

It does not mean the person has been found guilty.

Instead, the case will proceed to trial.

The details remain confidential until the grand jury proceedings begin, and the accused has the right to a defense.

Why Is It Called a Grand Jury?

It is called a grand jury because it typically consists of more jurors than a regular trial jury.

The term “grand” refers to the more significant number of jurors involved, usually between 16 and 23 members.

Unlike trial jurors, which decide guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, a grand jury’s decision leads to formal charges against the defendant.

The Constitution requires this similar process in federal felony cases, ensuring a fair and just legal procedure.

How Do Federal Prosecutors Decide to Seek an Indictment?

Federal prosecutors usually seek an indictment based on the evidence, the nature of the crime, and legal requirements.

They present the case to a grand jury, outlining the evidence and legal arguments.

If the grand jury finds reasonable doubt, they issue a true bill, leading to an indictment.

This process ensures that the charges are based on substantial evidence and that the defendant’s rights are protected.

Can a Person Be Found Not Guilty After an Indictment?

Yes, a person can be found not guilty after an indictment.

The accused can defend themselves in court, and the prosecution must prove their guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

If the prosecution fails to meet this standard, the defendant may be found not guilty.

Personal Injury Lawyer: How Can They Help?

Are you the victim of any negligence that led to criminal charges and an arrest?

A personal injury lawyer can assist you, the defendant, in navigating the legal complexities.

  • Personal injury cases: Specialized in handling cases where negligence has caused harm or loss.
  • Free consultation: Discuss your case without any financial obligation.
  • Contingency fee basis: Pay only if you win your case.
  • Contact at (888) 424-5757: Reach out for professional legal assistance.

An experienced criminal defense lawyer understands the intricacies of indictments and the criminal justice system.

They can provide valuable support, ensuring your rights are protected and you receive the compensation you deserve.


Free Consultation (888) 424-5757